Our Bakery

Hutton Farm Bakery

We believe in quality baking-the old fashioned way- in small batches. It is not the fastest way, nor is it the easiest, but we feel both our guests and our customers alike deserve only the best.

All of our baked goods are made from scratch- the old fashioned way, just like my grandparents taught me and how Mike’s grandparents ran their bakery. There are NO substitutes, NO shortcuts- only real, local and fresh ingredients handcrafted with integrity and quality you can taste in every bite. There is NO room for substitutions on our bakery! Only the unmistakable scent of real butter and baked goods coming out of our oven.

We appreciate our space in the tradition of old fashioned “scratch-made” bakers with fourth generation recipes all made on the premises, and each of them drizzled with passion and love. The touch of a baker requires skill and dedication to make ah-mazing products that will bring back delightful memories and innovate new ones. Although our bakery may be small, our intentions of distributing love and the spirit of our family traditions are through taste and quality.

- Reviews -

The Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies from Hutton Farm Bakery were Amazing. My daughters age 10 and 12 Loved them so much that I had to hide some for myself even from my husband.

A huge Thankyou to Mags @fingerlakesbb for making these for our Anniversary! These melt in your mouth little pieces of heaven were beyond amazing 🥰 German chocolate cupcakes with coconut pecan frosting are my hubby’s absolute favorite, so this was the perfect gift for him (ok I may have eaten 5 myself 😋) Forget about dinner we skipped right to dessert! I do believe this will be an Anniversary tradition from now on, in fact Mags can you just make all my baked goodies from here on out cuz you’re the bomb girl 💣🙏🏻😍😋

If you haven't tried Hutton Farm Bakery, you are missing out on the BEST baked goods around! The chocolate chip cookies were incredible! I can't wait to buy them in the future but my pants are warning me to wait a while! The blueberry muffins were so moist and delicious! You seriously need to get yourself some Hutton Farm Bakery goodies! You will be so happy you did!

The Moscato cupcakes were the fluffiest vanilla cupcakes, I ever had. Each bite was sweet, delicious and a little boozy. It was not too sweet or over powering but just right. the Moscato added to the cupcakes made them light in the center and added a boost in flavor. Definitely would order again.

This place is gorgeous with amazing attention to detail and love in every corner...But...the bakery is to die for! Oh my gosh! Delicious! And the peanut butter fudge is fabulous and absolutely melts in your mouth. I’m looking forward to trying everything! I highly recommend staying here AND eating here 😁
Thoughtful amenities · Spacious rooms

"The cupcakes and cookies from Hutton Farm were absolutely delicious!!! We loved the way the hint of red wine accented the cherry filling and the rich dark chocolate flavor. Both the cookies and cupcakes were unique; we had not had anything quite like them before. They did not stick around long--they were "gobbled up"!"